top of page

JUST MY OPINION: So long to the Boy Scouts of America:

The potential loss of identity for an organization like the Boy Scouts of America (BSA) would be a significant event with many sad implications. Here are several reasons why this would be a cause for concern:

1. Loss of Historical Significance:

   - The Boy Scouts of America has been integral to American culture since its founding in 1910. It has a history of preparing young men for leadership and responsible citizenship. The loss of its distinct identity could mean diluting this rich history and the traditions that have been part of millions of American lives across multiple generations.

2. Erosion of Core Values:

   - The BSA is built on a foundation of core values—outlined in the Scout Oath and Law—that include loyalty, helpfulness, kindness, bravery, and reverence, among others. These principles are designed to shape character and ethical decision-making. A loss of identity might lead to these values becoming less emphasized or taught, diminishing their role in forming the character of young individuals.

3. Impact on Community Service:

   - Boy Scouts are known for their commitment to community service, from local projects like park cleanups and building community gardens to Eagle Scout projects that often aim to solve community issues on a larger scale. If the BSA loses its identity, the organizational drive and structure that support such extensive community service efforts could wane, potentially reducing the positive impact on communities.

4. Weakening of Brotherhood and Mentorship:

   - Part of what makes the BSA unique is its sense of brotherhood and the mentorship between older and younger scouts and between scouts and their leaders. This mentoring environment helps in the personal development of young boys and teens. A diminished organizational identity could disrupt these relationships, leading to fewer opportunities for mentorship and personal growth.

5. Diminishment of Unique Educational Opportunities:

   - The BSA offers unique educational experiences that are hard to find elsewhere, such as wilderness survival, orienteering, and various physically and intellectually challenging activities. These experiences are not only about skill-building but also about fostering self-reliance and confidence. A loss of identity might mean these programs are no longer offered or are significantly altered, reducing valuable learning opportunities.

6. Cultural Shifts:

   - As society changes, organizations like the BSA often need to adapt. However, there's a balance between adapting to modern needs and losing the essence of what made the organization valuable and distinctive in the first place. Losing its identity might mean the BSA becomes unrecognizable to alums and potential new members, possibly leading to decreased engagement and support.

7. Loss of a Safe Space:

   - For many young individuals, the Boy Scouts is a safe space where they can escape other pressures of life, enjoy camaraderie, and just be themselves while learning valuable life skills. Dissolving its identity might compromise this safe haven, leaving fewer options for those seeking such a supportive environment.

The potential fading of the Boy Scouts' identity represents not just a transformation of an organization but a possible loss of a cultural and formative pillar in American society. As communities and supporters of the BSA consider its future, reflecting on these aspects can help guide decisions that preserve the best of what the Boy Scouts of America has historically stood for while embracing necessary evolution.

0 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

Biblical Principles and Scriptures for Healing.

1. God's Love and Compassion Psalm 34:18: "The Lord is close to the brokenhearted and saves those who are crushed in spirit." Jeremiah 31:3: "The Lord appeared to us in the past, saying: 'I have loved


bottom of page